The 1886 Revelation · Historical sourcebook
Woolley & the witnesses
Separate the dates of the claimed events from the dates when witnesses recorded their accounts.
In this chapter
How the Woolley accounts developed
Lorin C. Woolley was the son of John W. Woolley, Taylor’s host at Centerville. Accounts recorded between 1897 and 1929 preserve different parts of the story he told.
1897 · Andrew Kimball records an account of a visitation
In a diary entry dated January 25, 1897, Andrew Kimball recorded Elder Woolley’s testimony that he had seen Joseph Smith, Brigham Young and Heber C. Kimball appear to President Taylor at John Woolley’s house. Fred C. Collier identifies the speaker as Lorin and prints the passage on pp. 26–27. The quoted entry gives neither a date for the visitation nor any instructions about marriage. It traces a visitation story to at least 1897. The words available here come through Collier’s transcription of Andrew Kimball’s diary.
1912 · Woolley distinguishes what he heard from what Taylor told him
Woolley dated his Statement of Facts October 6, 1912. He placed the incident in late September 1886 and said he had forgotten the exact day. On guard outside Taylor’s room, he remembered light, voices and Taylor’s bright countenance the following morning. Taylor identified his visitor as Joseph Smith. Woolley also recalled hearing Taylor reject a proposed document that afternoon. In the surviving reproduction the story ends there. The details about Jesus and the five appointments appear in other accounts. Anderson’s chapter 1, note 2, describes changes to a list of attendees on his photostat.
1922 · Two diary entries preserve different chains of testimony
On March 12, Joseph W. Musser heard Daniel R. Bateman describe Taylor’s radiant appearance, a proposed manifesto and visits from Joseph Smith and Jesus Christ. Musser copied the revelation into his journal. The roughly two hundred people in his entry attended the 1922 gathering at Nathaniel Baldwin’s home. On June 14, Musser recorded what John T. Clark had heard from Lorin Woolley a few days earlier. Woolley said Taylor had ordained him an apostle in 1886 and given him a particular mission concerning celestial marriage. That entry names one recipient.
1929 · Woolley names five recipients
The account dated September 22, 1929, printed in the Supplement around 1934, places a meeting of thirteen on September 27, 1886. Woolley describes eight hours together and says Taylor sat down to write the revelation. He then names Samuel Bateman, Charles H. Wilcken, George Q. Cannon, John W. Woolley and himself as recipients of authority to perform plural marriages and commission successors. The printed testimony spells Wilcken’s name “Wilkins.” Its description of the five appointments appears on p. 60. The September 1886 manuscript itself addresses John and names no appointees.
Who witnessed which events?
The records distinguish attendance in the Woolley home, observations outside Taylor’s room, and the later claim that Taylor laid hands on five men.
Cannon describes the Sunday gathering and Monday’s business
George Q. Cannon’s journal names nine elders and three women at the 2:30 p.m. Sunday meeting on September 26, 1886. He had spent the morning with Hyrum B. Clawson on matters including Arizona politics. For Monday the 27th he reports usual business and improvement in his own health. He records no eight-hour meeting, ordinations or visitation. Three leaves are missing within the September 29 entry. The entries for September 26, 27 and 28 survive. Cannon confirms the gathering on Sunday. His brief Monday entry leaves the detailed later narrative without contemporary confirmation from him.
Daniel Bateman explains where his knowledge ends
Daniel R. Bateman affirmed that he attended the larger gathering. On p. 62 of the Supplement he specifically says he was absent when Taylor set the five apart. He said he heard accounts of that ceremony from both John W. and Lorin C. Woolley on different occasions. Samuel Bateman, named among the five, was a different man. The same printed page records a May 4, 1934 oath by J. Leslie Broadbent, John Y. Barlow and Joseph W. Musser. They attested to the accuracy of a copy of statements signed in their presence in 1929. Their signatures document how the testimony was transmitted.
George Earl’s two accounts describe the limits of his memory
The 1929 testimony lists George Earl among the thirteen. Musser’s account of a November 3, 1936 interview says Earl remembered a gathering, had been a fifteen-year-old chore boy moving in and out, and trusted the Woolleys and Daniel Bateman. He recalled few details of the instructions. In a statement dated August 2, 1949, Earl described his work at the home, Sunday meetings and carrying mail. He expressly denied seeing Taylor suspended in the air or hearing the reported sermon. The 1936 interview comes through Musser. Anderson reproduces Earl’s own later statement.
A group of seven can be traced from 1929 to 1933
Joseph Lyman Jessop’s January 13, 1934 diary names the six men who joined Lorin Woolley. J. Leslie Broadbent and John Y. Barlow were appointed in March 1929, followed by Joseph W. Musser, Charles F. Zitting, LeGrand Woolley and Louis Kelsch. Jessop described a body of seven in his own time. Woolley’s 1929 testimony placed five appointments in 1886. Hales compares that earlier claim with diaries kept in 1886. Collier disputes the proposed historical ancestry of a formal Council of Friends, and Kraut accepts that seven were selected while questioning whether they were intended to act as a formal quorum.