The 1886 Revelation · Historical sourcebook
The document’s journey
Follow the manuscript from family papers and early printings to the First Presidency in 1933.
In this chapter
From family papers to the First Presidency
The family’s accounts, the printed editions and the First Presidency’s correspondence preserve different stages in the life of the document.
The family and Rodney Badger held the paper
John W. Taylor testified in 1911 that he found the revelation on his father’s desk after his death. An undated copy in an unidentified Taylor family member’s hand says R. C. Badger held the original in safe deposit. Joseph F. Smith Jr. told the hearing that Rodney Badger had lent him the original to copy. D. Michael Quinn proposed an earlier transfer to Wilford Woodruff in 1887. His evidence was an envelope concerning a different revelation, dated November 19, 1877. Its direction to send papers to Woodruff leaves the inclusion of the 1886 manuscript uncertain.
Print carried two readings of the same phrase
John T. Clark printed the text on pages 124–125 of One Mighty and Strong, generally dated to about 1922. The Bancroft Library copy includes a preface added in 1930. Clark described delaying distribution because the printing contained errors. Joseph Leslie Broadbent also printed the revelation in Celestial Marriage? around 1927, on pages 15–16. In October 1938, Truth printed a photographic facsimile alongside a transcription on pages 84–86. Clark’s printing reads “now pleasing.” The photograph and the 1909 typescript support the reading in Truth, “more pleasing.”
The First Presidency denied the revelation’s existence
On June 17, 1933, Heber J. Grant, Anthony W. Ivins and J. Reuben Clark Jr. signed a statement printed in the Church Section of the Deseret News. Page 4, column 2 says the Church archives contained no evidence for the revelation and expressly denies its existence. The statement then argues that even if Taylor had received it, the Church had never adopted it and had subsequently adopted the Manifesto. It separately disputes the alleged ordinations. The surviving manuscript and the dated 1909 copy contradict the denial of existence.
The original reached Grant the following month
Clark’s July 18, 1933 memorandum records Ivins relaying Nellie Taylor’s account of finding the paper among her husband John W.’s effects and passing it to Frank Y. Taylor. Frank delivered the original in its envelope to Grant about July 15. On July 17 Grant wrote John Taylor’s death date on the reverse of the second sheet. Subsequent letters took up the issue of authority. Ivins described an unsigned pencil document on February 10, 1934. On December 31, Melvin J. Ballard accepted Taylor’s handwriting and argued that the writing had never bound the Church.