The 1886 Revelation · Historical sourcebook
The earliest readers, 1889–1911
Family readings, apostolic diaries, and the revelation’s appearance at John W. Taylor’s disciplinary hearing.
In this chapter
The earliest readers, 1889–1911
At a family dinner and in meetings of the Twelve, John W. Taylor explained what he understood his father’s revelation to mean.
A dinner guest heard the document read
On March 5, 1889, Samuel A. Woolley recorded having dinner at John W. Taylor’s home. He heard John W. read a revelation that he described as being in his father’s handwriting. Woolley introduced his account of the words as approximate. His references to the law of marriage, Joseph’s earlier revelation, human agency and the obligation to obey closely match the surviving manuscript. Woolley’s entry gives no date for the revelation. It puts a reading of a matching document more than a year before Woodruff’s Manifesto.
Grant recorded two different revelations
At a September 30, 1890 meeting of the Twelve, Heber J. Grant heard John W. Taylor explain his initial anger at the Manifesto. On pages 443–444 of Grant’s diary typescript, John W. recalled a revelation from Woodruff that had been read to the apostles. He then described a second text found among his father’s papers. He understood it as an answer to his father’s prayer about discontinuing plural marriage. Grant recorded John W.’s eventual acceptance of the Manifesto. The passage supplies the son’s interpretation and leaves the father’s document undated.
John W. reported keeping the revelation
Abraham H. Cannon recorded an April 1, 1892 meeting attended by seven apostles in an upstairs room of the Historian’s Office. On page 82, John W. said he possessed the revelation he had found among his father’s papers. He understood it to mean that the principle of plural marriage would endure. He also said he had voted to sustain the Manifesto and would help maintain it, even as he questioned the decision. Cannon heard these remarks in person. The entry gives no indication that John W. displayed the manuscript that afternoon.
The text was read at the 1911 hearing
A typescript dated August 3, 1909 identifies Joseph F. Smith Jr. as the copyist and the original manuscript as his source. During John W.’s 1911 disciplinary hearing, Smith explained that he had filed his copy in the Historian’s Office. Charles W. Penrose read the revelation aloud. John W. linked its language about agency to individual responsibility. Francis M. Lyman allowed for suspension of the practice, and Orson F. Whitney saw no grant of authority to officiate. The March 28 decision gave insubordination to Church government and discipline as the ground for excommunication.