The 1886 Revelation · Historical sourcebook
Why the interpretations diverge
A continuing covenant, competing claims of authority, and the limits of the surviving evidence.
In this chapter
Why the interpretations diverge
The same words can serve two arguments because the parties disagree about both the scope of the covenant and the location of authority.
The case for continuing plural marriage
A strong historical case for a plural-marriage referent begins with Taylor’s own October 1882 language and his contemporaries’ understanding of Abraham’s law. His son expressly connected the later revelation with plurality before Lorin Woolley published his detailed account. Taylor himself went into hiding, and Woodruff later described the danger to the temples. For a continuationist, all this makes a purely abstract reading implausible. It still leaves a further question: did an enduring covenant require ongoing solemnization, and by whom? The five appointments and authority after the Manifesto depend on additional testimony.
The case for continuing authority in the Church
Section 132 describes an eternal bond and regulates the authority to seal it. In 1890 the conference resolution accepting the Manifesto expressly appealed to the president’s keys. In his 1934 letter Melvin J. Ballard accepted Taylor’s handwriting while distinguishing eternal marriage from its plural form; he argued that members could not authorize the practice for themselves. Today the Church expressly acknowledges that some nineteenth-century leaders taught plurality as necessary for exaltation and says that is not its doctrine. This interpretation explains how the Church can accept the writing as historical without accepting continuing plural marriages as lawful ordinances.
What an argument for independent succession must demonstrate
Kraut treated the obligation to preserve plural marriage as capable of outlasting institutional restrictions. The Openshaws’ 2008 defense makes priesthood succession its central issue and presents Woolley’s narrative and other testimonies together. Hales challenges whether surviving witnesses independently establish the appointment of the five. Collier accepts portions of the tradition but questions some later institutional reconstructions. These writers are sources for different arguments. The critical test is to trace each claimed appointment to a dated account, ask whether the recorder saw it, and determine whether apparently separate witnesses repeat the same speaker.
What the evidence can settle
The manuscript’s existence, its date, its archival attribution and its circulation before 1890 are strongly supported. A historical connection with plural marriage is better supported than an interpretation that excludes it. The manuscript alone cannot decide how broadly the requirement applied, whether a heavenly visitation occurred, or whether anyone inherited authority outside the Church. No contemporaneous record examined here independently attests the five appointments described in the 1929 account. That is a judgment about the evidence reviewed, not a verdict on anyone’s religious experience. A later recollection can be historically important even where a claimed event remains uncorroborated.