The 1886
Revelation

The 1886 Revelation · Historical sourcebook

Four questions the sources can answer

Canonization, contemporary diaries, the reach of the Manifesto, and the survival of existing families.

In this chapter

Four questions the sources can answer

Publication, eyewitness testimony, Church jurisdiction, and the survival of existing families each left a different kind of record.

C49Documentary comparison

Why is the 1843 revelation in scripture while the 1886 document is not?

Joseph Smith’s 1843 revelation took a public path that can be documented: the Kingsbury copy supplied the text printed in a Deseret News extra on September 14, 1852, after the public announcement of plural marriage; in 1876 it became section 132 of the Doctrine and Covenants. Private origin therefore does not in itself settle the eventual status of a text. For the 1886 document we have early family readings, copies, later publications and a disciplinary hearing, but no comparable record of adoption into the Church’s canon. The Church continues to withhold authoritative standing from it.

SourcesS11 S63 S05 S08 S27 S33
C50Contemporary records in different editions

Do other records describe September 27 itself?

Yes. Samuel Bateman’s September 27 diary as reproduced by J. Max Anderson mentions reading, playing quoits, loading barley, and carrying mail at night. In Taylor’s daily journal for that date, secretary L. John Nuttall records recommends signed, letters received and answered, and Taylor playing quoits both morning and afternoon. Neither entry reports the unusual meeting; their affirmative details are harder to reconcile with a continuous gathering from about 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. than silence alone would be. These transcriptions and Cannon’s journal bear on the schedule, not on whether Taylor could have written the manuscript privately.

SourcesS64 S18 S24 S39 S01
C51Signed statement and historical context

What did Lorenzo Snow say about the geographical reach of the Manifesto?

On January 8, 1900, President Lorenzo Snow publicly disclaimed any authority for a member or Church officer to enter into or perform plural marriages. He addressed claims about Church conduct and responsibility for violating civil law. His signed statement survives in a collection of U.S. diplomatic papers concerning Denmark. The Church’s historical essay interprets his position as worldwide and acknowledges that a few marriages continued, probably without his knowledge or approval. Distinguish Snow’s rule from the historical question of what individuals actually did. His statement falls between the two Manifestos.

SourcesS65 S21 S38
C52Documented practice and evidentiary inference

What happened to marriages that already existed?

Ending new marriages and ending existing households were different decisions. The 1890 text advised against contracting marriages forbidden by law; it gave no uniform direction to dissolve existing families. The Church’s historical essay describes separations, continued support without cohabitation, and continuing conjugal relationships. It also records leaders condemning husbands who used the Manifesto to abandon wives or children. Some families remained together after 1904. A child born after 1890 therefore does not, by date alone, prove that the parents contracted a new marriage after the Manifesto. Evidence of when a union began is needed.

SourcesS20 S21 S22
Continue readingChronology