The 1886
Revelation

The 1886 Revelation · Historical sourcebook

Families, historians & public memory

The document’s preservation, changing public descriptions, and the significance of its digital release.

In this chapter

Families, historians, and public memory

The public story about this document changed more than once. It matters who was speaking, when, and whether the words represented a family, an individual leader, or the Church.

C41Family testimony and administrative record

A woman’s role in preserving the document

On September 1, 1934, Douglas M. Todd Sr. recorded a conversation with his sister Nellie Taylor. She said that Ellen Sanberg, another wife of John W. Taylor, had kept the paper after his death, that copies were made, and that she herself recovered it from Ellen and took it to Frank Y. Taylor. Clark’s memorandum instead relays a report that Nellie found it among her husband’s papers. Both accounts say she gave it to Frank. Nellie also passed on her husband’s description of an apostolic gathering. In this telling John W. stood guard outside the meeting. That limits what he could have known directly about its proceedings.

SourcesS61 S04 S08 S49
C42Published book and private diary

A 1974 denunciation and a 1976 diary

In The Way of the Master (1974), apostle Mark E. Petersen described the revelation as a fabrication used to claim secret authority. Two years later, Church historian Leonard J. Arrington recorded in his diary that the revelation was probably genuine; the entry is dated January 30, 1976. His February 15, 1973 entry reports Joseph Anderson’s account of earlier doubts attributed to Joseph Fielding Smith. These are differently situated sources: a published argument, a historian’s private assessment, and a report of someone else’s view. Gagliano’s 2026 prose dates the later entry correctly, but footnote 3 gives July.

SourcesS31 S48 S43
C43Institutional sources and contemporary reporting

What changed in 2025

The Church’s official 2020 history, Saints, already mentioned a purported September 27 revelation and attributed the plural marriage interpretation to John W. Taylor. Benjamin Park reported that the archival images appeared online June 14, 2025. In July, the Church told KUER that the private writing had never been presented to its leadership or members and had never qualified as authoritative. The statement does not say “for adoption.” The 1911 reading took place at a disciplinary hearing; formal submission for adoption is a distinct act. The Church History Library’s September 22 collections notice lists MS 34928. June marks public access to the digitized collection, rather than first publication of the words, first discussion by apostles, or canonization.

SourcesS32 S50 S33 S02 S08 S27
C44Interview and historical interpretation

What the release meant to readers

In KUER’s interview, fundamentalist Benjamin Shaffer described why people who had already seen the photograph still cared about its publication: institutional recognition of the paper mattered to families who had heard it dismissed. Cristina M. Gagliano’s 2026 study likewise attends to the unequal ways that institutional and family memories have circulated. These sources document how named people understood the release. They do not establish a single reaction among all fundamentalists, nor verify the events described in Woolley’s testimony. For a website, keeping the speaker’s name attached preserves the human significance without claiming a consensus.

SourcesS33 S43 S27
Continue readingWhy readings differ