The 1886
Revelation

The 1886 Revelation · Historical sourcebook

Reading Ogden Kraut

Four works, their sources, and the distinction between reproduced testimony and theological interpretation.

In this chapter

Reading Ogden Kraut’s four works

Kraut’s online catalog preserves the printed page numbers in brackets. These page references identify the exact places where he reproduces testimony or draws a theological conclusion.

C37Compilation checked against two manuscripts

Revelations 1880–1890 · Two dates can be corrected

Kraut’s 1970 compilation, reprinted in 1979 and 1986, places the text, an apostle’s journal, family recollections and excerpts from the 1911 hearings together on pp. 30–37. The preface asks readers to approach the collection as apocryphal writings. On p. 30 the heading dates Taylor’s revelation September 26. The surviving manuscript gives September 27. Note 1 on p. 31 attributes Abraham H. Cannon’s report of John W. Taylor’s remarks to March 29, 1892. The scanned diary typescript places those remarks under April 1 on p. 82. The remarks themselves are present.

SourcesS51 S34 S01 S07
C38Source comparison and author’s interpretation

The Church and the Priesthood · One chapter joins two tellings

In chapter 5, pp. 50–52, Kraut prints the 1912 statement and credits Anderson’s book. On pp. 52–53 he continues with passages from Truth describing the revelation being written and authority conferred. The change of source comes immediately after Woolley’s 1912 signature. A reader quoting the appointments can trace them to the expanded testimony printed in the Supplement. On pp. 54–55 Kraut inserts plural marriage in brackets while interpreting the manuscript’s terms about the law and Abraham. Those brackets identify what Kraut believed the words meant.

SourcesS35 S23 S24 S01
C39Abridged quotation and editorial framing

Holy Priesthood, volume 4 · The law of celestial marriage

On pp. 214–216 of The History and Law of Plural Marriage, Kraut places Taylor between two public arguments about divine law. First he quotes Lorenzo Snow’s response to a prosecutor who predicted that prosecution would bring a change in doctrine. Then he gives selected lines of Taylor’s revelation, followed by a December 1886 Deseret Evening News editorial on obedience to God. His selection emphasizes the endurance of God’s covenants. Asterisks mark omissions, including the discussion of agency. The omitted passage matters to any reader weighing how a continuing obligation could be left to individual choice.

SourcesS36 S01
C40Kraut’s stated position on succession

Holy Priesthood, volume 6 · What authority did Kraut claim?

On pp. 249–258 Kraut treats the commissions as authority to live plural marriage, solemnize plural sealings and authorize other men to do the same. That interpretation joins the manuscript’s statements about divine law to the powers described in Woolley’s later testimony. Pages 292–297 ask who could claim those powers. On p. 296 Kraut accepts the selection of seven men by the early 1930s but questions whether they were meant to govern as a formal quorum. He quotes Collier’s objection to projecting a Council of Friends back to Joseph Smith. For Kraut, tracing who could solemnize a marriage still left open the question of who could govern those who practiced it.

SourcesS37 S01 S24 S41
Continue readingPublic memory & response