The 1886
Revelation

The 1886 Revelation · Historical sourcebook

The teachings before 1886

Marriage, the works of Abraham, and the authority to seal: the language Taylor inherited and used.

In this chapter

Marriage, exaltation, and the works of Abraham

Joseph Smith’s instructions and Brigham Young’s sermons supplied the language Taylor and his readers brought to the 1886 document.

C09Contemporary journal and canonical text

What William Clayton recorded in May 1843

On May 16, 1843, at the Johnson home in Macedonia, Illinois, Joseph Smith taught that a husband and wife could enter an everlasting covenant through priesthood authority and have children in the resurrection. William Clayton, who attended, copied his account into his journal about May 19. The part now represented by Doctrine and Covenants 131:1–4 says that the highest celestial glory requires entry into an order of the priesthood. The bracketed explanation identifying that order as the new and everlasting covenant of marriage in verse 2 is a later clarification. Clayton’s surrounding sentences already connect the teaching to marriage.

SourcesS10 S44
C10Manuscript and canonical text

The July revelation places sealing under a governing authority

On July 12, 1843, in Nauvoo, Joseph Smith dictated a revelation on marriage to William Clayton. The surviving early manuscript is Joseph C. Kingsbury’s copy. Now Doctrine and Covenants 132, it opens by acknowledging Joseph’s question about the biblical patriarchs’ wives and concubines. Verse 7 identifies one person at a time who holds the governing keys. Verses 19–20 describe a man and wife receiving exaltation through a marriage sealed with divine authorization. The text thus raises a question that would matter after 1886. Who could authorize a particular marriage under a covenant understood to endure?

SourcesS11 S12
C11Comparison of the two texts

What the instruction to do Abraham’s works includes

Doctrine and Covenants 132:32 directs hearers to do the works of Abraham. Verses 34–35 explain that Sarah gave Hagar to Abraham in obedience to a divine command. Verse 36 next recalls Abraham’s willingness to offer Isaac. Verse 37 returns to his concubines, while verses 38–39 distinguish unions the Lord authorized from David’s taking of Uriah’s wife. When Taylor’s 1886 text invokes Abraham, the earlier revelation gives readers reason to hear a reference to plural marriage. Its adjoining examples also make obedience to a particular divine command part of the comparison.

SourcesS01 S12
C12Published report compared with shorthand

Brigham Young’s sermon in print and shorthand

At the Bowery in Great Salt Lake City on August 19, 1866, Brigham Young tied plural marriage to the blessings promised to Abraham. The Journal of Discourses says those seeking those blessings must embrace the principle “at least in your faith” and speaks of men entering polygamy to become gods. LaJean Purcell Carruth’s transcription of George D. Watt’s shorthand includes both men and women in the corresponding passage. It also qualifies the duty to practice with “if you have the privilege.” The differences matter when quoting Young about a believer who lacked the opportunity to enter a plural marriage.

SourcesS13 S45

What John Taylor taught before 1886

Taylor addressed marriage in private revelation, discussions with other leaders, and a public pamphlet while federal law made the conduct of plural households a criminal issue.

C13Revelation transcription and source comparison

Taylor’s June 1882 question concerned whom the law bound

On June 25–26, 1882, Taylor asked whether the law of celestial marriage applied to the nation or the world. His written answer placed the covenant within acceptance of the gospel and quoted the 1843 revelation, including its provision for one holder of sealing authority. It recognized other people’s freedom to reject the teaching and instructed believers to defend their rights through legal and constitutional means. The dated transcription and the narrative in the BYU study agree on June. Footnote 27 in that study prints April. Taylor received a separate revelation concerning the Council of Fifty on June 27.

SourcesS14 S42
C14Contemporary apostolic diaries

How the apostles understood Taylor’s October revelation

On October 13, 1882, Taylor’s revelation called George Teasdale and Heber J. Grant to the apostleship. It conditioned Seymour B. Young’s appointment to the Presidency of the Seventy on obeying divine law. George Q. Cannon recorded that day that the condition concerned celestial marriage. On October 14, Cannon described stake presidents who had yet to enter the practice facing pressure to do so or step down. Wilford Woodruff’s entry for the same meeting ties the patriarchal law of marriage to the law of Abraham. The two diaries show what the scriptural language asked of particular leaders.

SourcesS15 S16 S42
C15Published statement by Taylor

On Marriage placed the decision and the ceremony in different hands

In his 1882 pamphlet On Marriage, Taylor wrote that civil laws recognizing one wife or several governed earthly relations. He described celestial marriage as an eternal covenant whose administration belonged to the appointed priesthood authorities. He also authorized bishops to perform marriages for members in good standing who lacked a recommendation for the House of the Lord. Taylor defended their freedom to accept or decline the higher covenant, even as he reserved judgment about worthiness and access to its ordinances to Church officers. The final page records that he had submitted these teachings to the Council of the Apostles and received its approval.

SourcesS17
C16Federal statutes and contemporary journal

Taylor wrote in hiding under the 1882 federal law

The Edmunds Act of March 22, 1882, made a man’s cohabitation with more than one woman a misdemeanor in a federal territory. A prosecution could therefore concern an existing household as well as a new marriage. After his last public sermon on February 1, 1885, Taylor continued to lead through correspondence and trusted associates while moving between places of concealment. George Q. Cannon’s September 1886 journal identifies John W. Woolley’s home as one such place. The Edmunds–Tucker Act’s dissolution of the Church corporation came in March 1887, several months after Taylor dated his revelation.

SourcesS09 S18 S52 S53
Continue readingThe Manifestos